TOS - 1.19 - Arena

Despite only a passing knowledge of the Original Series prior to this Trekaton, I was of course aware of “Arena” as the famous episode in which Kirk fights a man in an unconvincing reptile costume on Vasquez Rocks. I was however surprised that this set piece only takes up the second half of the episode. Before that, we get a sequence where Kirk and his landing party are under siege on Sestus III from a mysterious alien threat and then the Enterprise chasing down the alien ship in a manner that is reminiscent of “Balance Of Terror”. The difference from that episode is we see nothing of the alien threat until Kirk meets its captain on the battle planet, and we don’t get to understand the Gorn’s perspective in the way that we did for the Romulans in the previous episode. However, it is soon clear that this is very deliberate, with the episode setting up the Gorn as Bug Eyed Monsters for Kirk to take down, before ultimately revealing that they may well have a point in the conflict. This is a clever idea, but the execution is unfortunately too heavily dependent upon Kirk seeking vengeance on the Gorn for their actions on Sestus III. Yes, this is needed so that the captain can develop his understanding later in the episode and overcome his prejudices by sparing his opponent, but it does seem somewhat out of character, especially in his dismissal of Spock when the Vulcan suggests a more measured response.

Given the notoriety of this episode, it is probably now a very different viewing experience compared with its original transmission. It does build anticipation to not show the Gorn for the first half of the episode, and so the revelation that they are so completely alien must have been a surprise at the time. Unfortunately, it probably goes without saying that the costume has not held up well, and this isn’t helped by the deliberately slow and ponderous motion of the poor stuntmen inside nor the comical sound effects that makes the Gorn captain sound like a heavy smoker. The attempts to show it as an immensely strong threat to Kirk are also undermined by the fact that the rocks that bounce off it are clearly artificial.

The battle between Kirk and the Gorn captain is initiated by the Metrons, a mysterious alien race who object to the violent natures of these creatures who have strayed into their territory. This gives a nice parallel since Kirk is able to overcome some of their prejudices about humans in the same way that he does in his attitude to the Gorn, but the sheer number of powerful and unknowable aliens being encountered by the Enterprise is now becoming somewhat repetitive. There is an interesting design choice when the Metron appears at the end as almost an stereotypical angel, only missing the wings. This seems to be picking up on the fact that the name Metron appears to derive from Metatron, an angel in Judaism and some Christian and Islamic traditions.

The structure of the episode does mean that the second half of the episode does struggle to find things for the rest of the Enterprise crew to do. Reading about the production of the episode, I see that the original outline focussed entirely on Kirk and his battle but it was felt that the viewer still needed regular check ins with Spock and the other. I can’t help but think that the original concept would have been the best way to go since these later Enterprise scenes don’t really add much; initially the crew are just wondering what is going on before the Metrons handily let them watch what is going on and we transition into something that looks a lot like a futuristic version of Gogglebox as we randomly switch back to the bridge for brief comments as to what Kirk is doing.

Planetary Gazetteer

Sestus III: An isolated planet on which an Earth Observation Outpost had been set up. The planet is apparently within the territory of the Gorn, leading to them defending themselves by destroying it. The outpost was commanded by Commodore Stone, who was famous for his hospitality, but is presumably killed in the Gorn attack.

The rocky planet on which Kirk fights the Gorn captain is not named.

Starship Spotting

The Enterprise can travel at up to Warp Factor 8, but extended periods at Warp Factors 7 and 8 lead to a risk of the engines exploding. The starship is seen to use photon torpedoes for the first time.

General Observations

• Two stardates are given in the episode – 3045.6 and 3046.2. This is a leap higher again after the very low date of 2124 used in “The Squire Of Gothos”.
• Grant Woods reprises the role of Kelowitz from “The Galileo Seven” (he was the crewman on a landing party searching the for the crashed shuttle who is seen reporting back to Kirk). The initial landing party on Sestus III also includes O'Herlihy and Lang, both of whom are killed (although only O'Herlihy wears a red shirt – Lang is in gold). We also meet yet another navigator, DePaul, played by Sean Kenney who had previously been hidden under make-up to portray the injured Captain Pike in “The Menagerie”.
• We’re led to believe that the Gorn destroyed the outpost on Sestus III in order to protect themselves from the Federation who have inadvertently stumbled into their territory. There is something to be said for this motivation, although they do seem to be a bit blood-thirsty in their response. And it isn’t clear why they deliberately lured the Enterprise to the planet. If they are planning to destroy it, then this seems a bit too premeditated for a defensive action, and they do seem to give up and leave pretty easily when Kirk sends the Enterprise away for a bit.
• Sulu is in command of the Enterprise when Kirk and Spock are off the ship (although still from the helm position, rather than the big chair). He apparently has extensive combat experience, which is interesting given that he was the ship’s physicist not that long ago in “Where No Man Has Gone Before”.
• Lt Harold, the survivor of the Sestus III outpost, wears the same tunic badge as Commander Hansen from Outpost 4 as seen in “Balance Of Terror”.
• There are some very melodramatic reactions from Uhura during the episode – she screams as Kirk is beamed away from the bridge (which is not after all that unusual an occurrence since the same thing happened in “The Squire Of Gothos”) and seems extremely worried for his safety during the battle.

Read more

TOS - 1.18 - The Squire Of Gothos

“The Squire Of Gothos” tells a very simple story in which the Enterprise crew is captured by Trelane, a mysterious being with immense powers who he is using them for his amusement. Despite not knowing a lot about the Original Series before embarking on this mission, I did have some awareness of this episode and the character of Trelane through having seen references to him being something of a precursor to Q, the recurring character from The Next Generation. And it is very easy to see where these comparisons come from, especially in the brief scene in which Trelane invades the bridge of the Enterprise. But, Trelane is more of a parochial character than Q, with a specific interest in Earth and the war-like ways of its inhabitants. He is also fallible – recreating the form of what he has seen but no substance (fire without heat and food without flavour). It also seems the Trelane isn’t a true god-like being, with his powers coming from some sort of machine, although the precise nature of this is never properly explained. As a result, the situation seems somewhat reminiscent of the similar magic technology employed by the pleasure planet in “Shore Leave”.

The simplicity of the plot means that there isn’t really a lot going on in the episode and it is somewhat repetitious, treading water a bit as the Enterprise crew escape from Trelane only to be captured again before escaping and being captured again - I think one round would have been sufficient to demonstrate the difficulty of their situation. But the plot isn’t really that important since the episode very much belongs to guest star William Campbell who gives a supremely entertaining performance as the mysterious alien as he manages to be balance menace with charm and playfulness. He leads us to share Kirk’s frustrations with Trelane, without ever being annoying. I was initially nervous that Trelane would be used as an excuse for continuing the painful whimsy of “Shore Leave”, especially when he initially communicates with the Enterprise (“Tallyho!), but the balance of humour and threat is much more successful here. There are some amusing moments in “The Squire Of Gothos” that are actually funny, including the eye-rolling and other deadpan responses of the crew to Trelane’s antics. I was also particularly fond of Yeoman Ross initially continuing to perform her duties on the Enterprise bridge despite still being dressed in period costume.

“The Squire Of Gothos” is an interesting episode for Kirk. Whilst he ends up in another big physical fight (albeit using swords rather than fists here), it is more satisfying that he uses his intelligence and the support of his team in trying to defeat Trelane, working out that the mirror is the source of his power and shooting that within his duel, a clever resolution as to what appears to be a difficult moral dilemma about shooting his unarmed captor.

The episode also succeeds in having a very satisfying conclusion. Yes, it is again something of a deus ex machine (like “Charlie X”, an episode that has a not dissimilar storyline) as Trelane’s parents turn up to stop everything just as it is looking bad for Kirk. But the revelation that Trelane is just a child does make sense, perfectly explaining his behaviour earlier in the episode. And it allows Campbell to give yet another layer to his performance, perfectly switching to being a believable spoilt child fighting with him mum and dad.

Planetary Gazetteer

Beta VI: An Earth colony in Quadrant 904 to which the Enterprise is travelling before it gets diverted by Trelane.

Gothos: An artificial planet created by Trelane within a “star desert” (an area of space devoid of stars) that is 900 light years from Earth. It consists of iron-silica and is a somewhat hostile environment since it has an extremely hot, toxic atmosphere devoid of oxygen and is subject to continuous volcanic eruptions. This is about from a small area that has been made habitable by Trelane.

Starship Spotting

Kirk says that the Enterpise has a crew of 400. This is a bit of a decrease from the figure of 433 given in “Shore Leave”, the previous episode to be made.

General Observations

• Four Stardates are given in the episode, ranging between 2124.5 and 2126.3. This is lowest since “Balance of Terror” given that more recent episodes have been above 2700.
• The Enterprise has yet another navigator, DeSalle, who has French ancestry. We meet another Yeoman of the Week, Teresa Ross, who, like Yeoman Barrows in the previous episode, gets to wear a pretty dress. There is another featured guest crew member, Carl Jaeger, who is a meteorologist with an expertise in geophysics.
• Amongst the hunting trophies seen in Trelane’s hall is the salt vampire from “The Man Trap”. McCoy does a double take as he walks past it.
• Uhura mentions “Space Fleet Command” as the organisation that controls the Enterprise which is odd given that the name of “Starfleet Command” had been established previously in “Court Martial”

Read more

TOS - 1.17 - Shore Leave

With the crew of the Enterprise stressed and in need of rest and relaxation, an uninhabited and idyllic Earth-like planet appears to provide a good opportunity for shore leave. Unfortunately, this is not a normal planet and the initial landing party soon start to experience physical manifestations of their thoughts and dreams.

Well, this is an odd episode. The fact that it starts with McCoy meeting the White Rabbit from “Alice in Wonderland” gives the impression that this is going to be a charming and comic instalment of the show. And it does feature its fair share of whimsy, including Kirk being presented with the return of Finnegan, his nemesis from the Academy, who is Irish (well, in the same way that Harry Mudd is Irish) and whose appearances are accompanied by an “amusing” Irish jig on the soundtrack. But the episode soon starts to get a lot darker, with what appears to be an attempted r**e of Yeoman of the Week Tonia Barrows and the actual death of McCoy as the manifestations become more dangerous. Strange energy drains leave the landing party cut off from the Enterprise and without functional weapons as the threats continue, and even Finnegan becomes more dangerous, resulting in a brutal (and seemingly never ending) fight between him and Kirk (and Kirk ruining yet another perfectly good tunic). This all leads to an odd mixture of tones, which the episode doesn’t successfully balance. The threats being thrown at the Enterprise crew also seem very random, leading to things feeling disjointed and somewhat episodic

“Shore Leave” does have a very different feel from its predecessors through featuring extensive location shooting. The locations that were chosen cleverly mirror the increase in threat as we move from beautiful parkland and woodland into desert as the episode progresses. I note that the desert scenes were filmed at Vasquez Rocks, a location that would soon become synonymous with the show.

After a strong female character in “The Menagerie”, the somewhat dated sexual politics of Star Trek again returns. Yeoman Barrow initially appears to be a more interesting a stronger character than her predecessors, but it isn’t long before she is in an unconvincing romance with Dr McCoy with the 13 year age gap between the actors making Bones seem more creepy than romantic, despite Barrows fawning over him. The yeoman soon starts dreaming of being a princess “to be protected and fought for” before ultimately being humiliated by McCoy when he subsequently becomes more interested in two scantily clad showgirls in a moment which I think that the script thinks we are supposed to find funny.

As an episode with a very bizarre premise, there is a lot depending on the script in its ability to provide a satisfying explanation for everything that has been going on. And here. “Shore Leave” definitely fails since, as we are rapidly approaching the 50 minute mark, an old man casually wanders in from the background to explain that everything is alright and that the whole planet is just an amusement park designed to give people whatever they want. Quite why this Caretaker has waited until now to reveal himself isn’t quite clear, especially after subjecting the landing party to stress, physical attacks and even death! Of course, McCoy does get better, but I was expecting it to have been revealed that his death had been an illusion, but no. it is explained that the inhabitants of the planet were simply able to cure his death through their amazing technology! I would have expected a doctor such as McCoy to be more interested in the implications of this, and not content to let it just be part of the first aid facilities on a pleasure planet! Even more bizarre is Kirk’s response to the revelation as to what has been going on, with absolutely no anger and a rather rash decision that this means that the planet is a suitable location for shore leave.after all. Has he immediately forgotten what has just happened and the lack of safeguards? I’m not sure that “just try not to think about anything that might be dangerous” is sufficient…

Planetary Gazetteer

The planet on which the episode takes place is never named. It is in the Omicron Delta region. No details are given about the race that is running this amusement planet and the nature of their really advanced technology is left frustratingly vague – all we see is something that looks like a flimsy television aerial that presumably allows the native species to read people’s mind and recreate whatever they find - somehow. These aliens are just too advanced for the Enterprise crew to understand and this is blindly accepted – which seems a little odd given that the whole mission of the starship is to seek out new life. I see that there is a return to the planet in the Animated Series, so it will be interesting to see if that provides any answers…

The showgirls that are recreated for McCoy are from a cabaret that he knows on Rigel II.

Starship Spotting

It is implied that the Enterprise has a crew of 433 (McCoy tells Sulu that Kirk is responsible for both of them and 430 others). This is comparable with the figure of 428 given in “Charlie X”.

General Observations

• The episode commences on Stardate 3025.3. It is a nice idea to have Kirk struggle with the Stardate in his log to indicate his own stress and tiredness, but it’s a bit over exaggerated in execution.
• Sulu’s interest in botany is mentioned again (following “Charlie X”). He also appears to be a collector of antique fire-arms and has been coveting an old-time police revolver. 
• James Doohan does not appear as Scotty in the episode.
• One of the landing party is Angela Teller, played by Barbara Baldavin who had previously appeared as Angela Martine in “Balance Of Terror”. I think we are supposed to assumed that this is the same character, with the change of surname being a mistake. She appears very friendly here with another crewman, Lt Esteban Rodriguez. This must make her seem somewhat callous when viewing the episodes in transmission order since “Shore Leave” comes immediately after “Balance Of Terror” in which Angela’s fiancé is killed on their wedding day!
• It is 15 years since Kirk was at the Academy and menaced by Finnegan. The version of Finnegan that is created by the is supposed to be still as young as from those days compared with Kirk’s “old man”, which makes the casting of Bruce Mars a bit odd (well, even odder than his inability to do an Irish accent), since Mars was 31 at the time that the episode was shot, and therefore only four years older than William Shatner. Finnegan wears a silver tunic with a small star-like emblem (essentially a smaller version of the one worn by Starbase personnel) – this is presumably the uniform of an Academy cadet.
• We meet yet another old flame of Kirk’s, a woman known only as Ruth who he knew 15 years previously (so presumably while he was at the Academy given the timeframe for that given in the episode). Kirk spends some quality time with this recreation of Ruth, which does some a little creepy when she is after all a copy of a real person.
• Teller and Rodriguez are unconvincingly menaced by a tiger that very obviously appears via stock footage. I was therefore subsequently very surprised when, in a later scene, the camera pans from Leonard Nimoy to a tiger in the same shot, proving that they did actually have the animal on set!

Read more

TOS - 1.16 - The Menagerie Part II

We are very conditioned these days to television shows featuring extensive “Previously on…” recaps, so it is quite refreshing that “The Menagerie Part II” takes a somewhat minimal approach to reminding viewers what has being gone – just some clever use of Kirk’s personal log and a repeat of the final scene of the first episode in which we learn that Kirk’s life is also at risk due to his ship receiving signals being received from Talos IV. However, this element of the plot seems to be forgotten pretty quickly as Spock explains that there is no way of stopping the transmissions and so everyone had better just sit down and watch “The Cage” anyway.

The bulk of the episode is now taken up with the material from “The Cage”, only returning occasionally to the present day for brief scenes for Kirk to explain what is going on and presumably also to wrap around the ad breaks. This means that there is a bit of a lost opportunity since present-day Pike is pretty much a passive observer as to what is going on – I know his condition limits his contribution to the story, but it would have been nice to have had some acknowledgement as to the effect on him of having to relive his experiences on Talos IV.

Pretty much all of the remaining material from original pilot is used within this second episode which therefore gives a faithful retelling of the events of “The Cage”. The main change is Vena is here left by herself rather than an illusory version of Pike. This cleverly allows that  footage to be repurposed at the climax of the episode to show the actual Pike restored to health via the powers of the Talosians and therefore getting a sort of happy ending with Vena. But this is probably the only satisfying element of the resolution of the story, which is otherwise somewhat rushed and doesn’t make that much sense. There is some tension as Kirk is unable to avoid having to find his friend guilty, but this is immediately undercut when it is revealed that Cdre Mendez as seen on the shuttlecraft and the Enterprise has actually been an illusion created by the Talosians and that the whole court martial has been plotted by Spock to delay Kirk from doing anything while they travel to Talos IV (so essentially wasting everyone’s time – I’m tempted to say that I know how they feel). This is the point at which the real Mendez conveniently choses to make contact with the Enterprise to reveal that he has also been watching “The Cage” back on Starbase 11 (I would love to know the circumstances) and he has decided to suspend General Order 7 on this occasion given how important Captain Pike is, thus allowing contact with Talos IV. Which does make one wonder how a single commodore can have such power, especially given how absolute the wording of the order was in the first episode (“no vessel under any condition, emergency or otherwise, is to visit Talos IV”).

This convenient suspension of General Order 7 also seems to make everything fine for Spock, who is no longer under the threat of punishment by death. Which does seem to forget about everything else that he did in essentially hi-jacking the episode, which all looked to be pretty serious crimes. And, despite his own protestations, I do still find it hard to see what he did as logical, especially as their must have been other ways of helping Pike (indeed, Kirk himself wonders why Spock was not open with him about what he wanted to do). So, whilst “The Menagerie” was a clever idea in allowing “The Cage” to be re-used, I can’t help feeling that the new envelope storyline wasn’t quite able to execute this in a satisfying manner.

Planetary Gazetteer

More of Talos IV, as “The Cage” and the first episode. We also again see Pike’s illusory trip to Rigel VII from “The Cage”.

General Observations

• Two Stardates are given in Kirk’s log – 3013.1 and 3013.2. These do at least follow on logically from the Stardates given in the first episode.
• The episode features very few of the regular characters – only Kirk and Spock with Uhura heard over an intercom. Lt Hansen again appears (previously seen in Part I and “Court Martial”)

Read more

TOS - 1.15 - The Menagerie Part I

Whilst I included “The Cage”, the original Star Trek pilot, in this Trekathon, it had been rejected by the network, leading to some reconfiguration of the series and an almost completely different cast, most obviously a new captain. This made it impossible to simply use “The Cage” as a regular episode with production of the first series proving problematic due to lengthy script developments and episodes exceeding their budget. It was actually a very clever idea to therefore re-use material from “The Cage” as flashbacks, reducing the amount of new material needed and to maximise this benefit across two episodes and thus leading to the only two-part story within the Original Series. It is fortunate that one character did survive from “The Cage” into the series proper, allowing the story to tie into Spock’s earlier career on the Enterprise.

I was aware of the background to “The Menagerie”, and was therefore somewhat surprised as to how little material from “The Cage” is actually used within the first episode (the flashbacks don’t start until almost 30 minutes in). Instead, the bulk of the episode concerns Spock’s plan to hi-jack the Enterprise and use it to transport Captain Pike to Talos IV. Spock’s actions in the episode are rather shocking with his lying, faking of orders and especially his fight with a perfectly innocent crewman but it is interesting that Kirk does not regard him as above suspicion for the odd things that are going on. This is in contrast to McCoy, who sees Spock as a much simpler character and is therefore completely wrong in his assessment of what Spock is capable of doing. This leads to a weakness of the two-part format since Spock’s actions at this point do indeed seem somewhat out of character. Yes, we are told about his loyalty to Pike, but nothing that we have seen nothing so far that has justified his actions, especially when Pike himself refuses Spock’s help.

Aside from Spock, Pike is the other linking factor between the new and old material. Pike is here, disfigured and disabled after being exposed to delta rays when rescuing cadets after an accident on a starship. He is now confined to a wheelchair, unable to speak and communicating only via a flashing light. It is a tragic fate for the character, and one that is probably more effective in retrospect given how likable the character was in Discovery (which did of course tie very much into this episode when Pike there saw a vision of this future) given that Jeffrey Hunter’s performance in “The Cage” isn’t really that engaging. Pike is here played by a new actor, Sean Kenney, who has been given some remarkable make-up that is effective in making him look suitably disturbing, as well as convincingly an older version of Hunter.

Spock’s plan involves abandoning Kirk at Starbase 11, although the captain gives chase in a stuttlecraft, accompanied by Cdre Mendez, the commander of the Starbase, making for a somewhat highly ranked crew, especially given Kirk’s high risk strategy to put himself at risk and force Spock to rescue him. This is at least successful in causing Spock to surrender and explain what his doing through a court martial being convened and allowing Spock to start showing “The Cage”, which is a little disconcerting as first as we cut straight from Spock as he has now been established to the shouty and emotional version from the original pilot. The material included here does including a surprising amount from from before the Enterprise actually gets to Talos IV such as the scene between Pike and Dr Boyce in his quarters that does feel very much like padding in this context.

The ending of the episode is surprisingly low key. Yes, the stakes have been raised with the revelation that Spock is receiving the transmissions from Talos IV and with the effect of putting Kirk at risk of execution as well as himself (which does all seem to be something of an exaggeration of the rules relating to contact with the planet as explained earlier in the episode), and there is still the on-going mystery of Spock’s motivations. But it is a bit odd to a modern viewer that there is no big cliff-hanger moment to convince viewers to tune in next time – only a caption slide just to make clear that there is more story to tell.

Planetary Gazetteer

See “The Cage” for details on Talos IV. The Enterprise visited the planet some 13 years prior to “The Menagerie” (and it is the only starship to have done so). Since then, Talos IV is the subject of Starfleet General Order 7 which means that it cannot be visited by any vessel with the death penalty as the punishment, making this the only remaining capital offence. This does seem to something of an over-reaction from Starfleet.

We return to Starbase 11 (as seen in “Court Marial”). The planet on which it is located is still not named.

Starship Spotting

Pike suffered his injuries when conducting an inspection of an old Class J starship that was being used for cadet training.

Kirk uses a Class F shuttlecraft to follow the Enterprise from Starbase 11. In the original episode it is just numbered (it is Starbase Shuttlecraft One), rather than having a name like those used by the Enterprise (although  the CGI model used in the remastered version of the episode is labelled as the Picasso).

General Observations

• Two Stardates are given for the present day events – 3012.4 and 3012.6. There are no Stardates retrospectively added to the flashbacks (the use of Stardates was established after "The Cage").
• Sulu is absent; his position at the helm is again taken by Lt Hansen who returns from “Court Martial”.
• The shortcomings of the production order are apparent with “The Menagerie” following immediately after “Court Martial” given that both featuring scenes on Starbase 11 and both concerning senior Enterprise officers being subject to a court martial. As well as the repetition, this apparently leads to a sudden turnover of staff on Starbase 11 with this now commanded by Cdre José Mendez rather than Cdre Stone as in the earlier episode (although Mendez wears gold rather than the red worn by Stone so it is possible that they could be commanding different parts of the Starbase). 
• Spock served under Pike on the Enterprise for 11 years, 4 months and 5 days. It is confirmed that Pike was Kirk’s immediate predecessor as the captain of the Enterprise.
• There is an utterly random moment when Kirk is introduced to Miss Piper, a crew member on Starbase 11 who knows the captain since they have a mutual friend, Lt Helen Johansson. This exchange and connection seems to have absolutely no relevance to the episode, so the precise point of it is somewhat unclear. The mention of Lt Johansson makes Kirk a little nervous, but it is not exactly surprising that there is yet another woman in his past.
• Pike is now a Fleet Captain, not a rank that we have heard of previously (checking subsequently I see that there is only one other Fleet Captain to appear anywhere within any Star Trek series).
• There is some clever casting with Malachi Throne playing Cdre Mendez. Throne has provided the voice for the Talosian Keeper in “The Cage” which meant that he was conveniently available when new dialogue was required for that character to enable it to repurposed within the context of the new story. The Keeper’s voice is electronically distorted here in order to hide the fact that this is the same actor. 

Read more

TOS - 1.14 - Court Martial

Star Trek enters the word of courtroom drama when Kirk is put on trial for apparently causing the death of one of Lt Cdr Benjamin Finney, the Enterprise's records office. It is alleged that Kirk is motivated in this since Finney is said to have held a grudge against Kirk for an incident in the past that resulted in Finney being demoted and affecting his subsequent career.

For the most part, "Court Martial" is an entertaining and successful attempt to merge Star Trek with another popular drama genre and it has a clever twist when it is revealed that Finney is not actually dead, having faked his death in order to punish Kirk. It is only when one actually things about the plot later that it doesn't really hang together with somewhat contradictory details about Kirk and Finney's relationship, given their apparent previous closeness in the past and Finney's absolute raving madness when he is revealed. The role of Finney's duaghter is also somewhat confused - she starts off angry with Kirk for supposedly killing her father, before later becoming reconciled with him for no apparent reason. This did lead me to suspect that she might actually be involved somehow, but I think this was more a result of the somewhat torturous scripting process that the episode went through, rather than being a clever red herring.

We meet an old flame of Kirk's in the form of Lt Areel Shaw (the first of many!). In a clever touch, it is revealed that she is prosecuting her old boyfriend. Shaw is probably one of the strongest and most successful female characters to have appeared in the show to this point - she is not patronised by the script and does her job to the best of her ability, rather than being influenced by Kirk's charms.

Kirk's legal counsel is another successful character - an amusing old school lawyer called Samuel T Cogley who believes in books rather than computers which makes for a nice counterpoint with the fact that evidence against Kirk is all coming from the Enterprise's computer including a video recording that shows the incident in a manner that is contrary to Kirk's memory. Indeed, this element of the plot seems amazingly prescient in the world of 2019 when there is increasing awareness of the danger of "deep fakes".

The fact that the Enterprise's own evidence appears to have been changed does at one point seem to suggest some sort of conspiracy against Kirk, with Shaw indicating that Starfleet wants to make an example of Kirk, suggesting that it is not necessarily a completely benevolent organisation. The face of Starfleet here is Commodore Stone, who heads the enquiry against Kirk and who has somewhat unclear motivations, especially given his frequently changing attitudes to the accused. Of course, it is ultimately revealed that Finney is behind everything and acting alone so the show isn't quite ready to start asking questions about is institutions...

Planetary Gazetteer

The episode takes place mainly on Starbase 11 which is located on an un-named mainly. This is the first time that we see a Starbase, which would later become space stations and therefore probably a more practical location for undertaking repairs to starships.

Cogley’s speech listing documents that mention human rights include the “Fundamental Declarations of the Martian colonies” and “the Statutes of Alpha III”

Starship Spotting

There is a status board in Commodore Stone's office which lists the registry numbers of ten starships including the Enterprise. This presumably represents all of the starships which are being repaired at Starbase 11. One of these is named as the Intrepid, which is lower priority than the Enterprise.

Kirk and Finney previously served together on the Republic, number 1371. Kirk was an ensign at this time and Finney was a lieutenant.

General Observations

• The episode takes place between Stardates 2947.3 and 2950.1. The incident that supposedly caused Finney's death took place on Stardate 2945.7.
• Sulu and Scotty do not appear in the episode. Sulu's place at the helm is taken by Lt Hansen. I would if he is any relation to Commander Hansen from "Balance Of Terror"?
• This is the first episode in which the organisation that operates the Enterprise is named as Starfleet Command. This is of course the name that would become fixed after a number of earlier attempts to establish a controlling organisation (UESPA in "Charlie X," Space Control in "Miri" and the Star Service in "The Conscience Of The King").
• Commodore Stone wears an insignia that is a multi-pointed star which appears to be one that is worn by Starbase personnel. The crewmen from other starships that taunt Kirk in the bar all wear delta insignia that is the same as that displayed by the Enterprise crew.
• McCoy holds the rank of Lieutenant Commander and an expert in space psychiatry. It is made explicit that Spock is a Lieutenant Commander and both First Officer and Science Officer of the Enterprise.
• Spock's race is again referred as "Vulcanian", rather than just Vulcan as would used later.
• Kirk is the very first starship captain to go on trial.
• The Enterprise has a Personnel Officer who is an un-named ensign. Finney was Records Officer.
• It is revealed that Finney has been hiding on the Enterprise all along, in presumably a very good hiding place. The method used to locate him is ridiculously convoluted - the starship is evacuated apart from the key personnel with McCoy then tracking everyone's heart beat and removing them from the monitoring on an individual basis. Clearly no one has heard of internal sensors at this point!
• The episode is pretty talky for much of its duration, so its inevitable that we get a big fight between Kirk and Finney. Unfortunately, the direction makes it very clear that this is a couple of stuntmen, and not William Shatner and Richard Webb.

Read more

TOS - 1.13 - The Galileo Seven

It is clear from “The Galileo Seven” quite how important a character Mr Spock is becoming, since this episode is very much focused on the Vulcan science officer and the challenges that he faces when in command on the shuttlecraft Galileo when it crashes on a hostile planet. The conflict between Spock’s logic and McCoy’s more emotional approach has already been a frequent element in previous episodes, but there it has been in the context of the two characters counselling Kirk. Here, it is very much about Spock having to make the decisions. This is a fascinating idea, but the concept is somewhat fumbled in execution. I think we are supposed to see that Spock is fallible, and his logic does lead to mistakes, but the script doesn’t make this absolutely explicit, presumably to avoid completely undermining the character. It also doesn’t help that guest crew members Boma and Gaetano week are completely unpleasant in their attitude to Spock in a manner reminiscent of the racism from “Balance Of Terror” and this does have the effect of making the viewer sympathetic to Spock. The script also avoids giving Spock any major dilemmas – when Scotty declares that there isn’t enough fuel to carry the full weight of the shuttlecraft and its crew, it looks like there is going to need to be a big decision from Spock as to who should be left behind. But this issue is removed almost as soon as it is introduced when one of the guest crew members of the week is conveniently killed.

The episode is also somewhat let down by certain elements of the design. It is certainly quite impressive to see a full-size shuttlecraft on the planet surface, but – blimey – the inside is incredibly boring, essentially consisting of two box-like rooms that seem to contain only office furniture. Additional threat to the shuttlecraft crew also comes from the natives of the planet. This is a fine idea but, for some inexplicable reason, the decision seems to have been made that these creatures will be giants, leading to comic sequences involving attacks by flying over-sized spears that would seem more suitable to a production of the pantomime “Jack And The Beanstalk”. And the idea is somewhat undermined by the glimpses that we get of the creatures which seem to show that they are barely larger than the Galileo crew members.

Kirk doesn’t get a lot to do in the episode. Somewhat conveniently, the phenomena that caused the Galileo to crash has blocked out the Enterprise’s sensors and hampering rescue efforts (presumably it would have been a very short episode otherwise) and further complications from the fact that the starship is carrying medical supplies that are urgently needed. The idea of introducing a time limit is a good one in placing pressure on Kirk as well as Spock, but unfortunately this is portrayed in a somewhat repetitive manner since we get a scene after scene in which Galactic High Commissioner Ferris strides on to the bridge to tell Kirk he hasn’t got much time. However, probably the most interesting element of this part of the episode is that Kirk does ultimately follow Ferris’s orders and abandon the search for his crew – a far cry from how Kirk has been seen as a maverick rulebreaker in more recent interpretations. And  the whole situation only arises since Kirk chooses to detour from an urgent medical mission in order to examine the strange phenomena. Which means, for all that Ferris is portrayed as an annoying bureaucrat who is making Kirk’s life difficult, he does kind of have a point in terms of stressing the importance of rushing to save a colony that is suffering from plague.

Ultimately, Scotty is able to work some magic and get the Galileo flying for a limited period, but this is just as the Enterprise as leaving. However, it is Spock who does save the day by sacrificing the shuttlecraft’s fuel which ignites and effectively leads to a flare that is spotted by Sulu. This does lead to a fun discussion as to whether this was Spock acting emotionally, although he is still able to justify his actions through logic. This results in a final scene in which the whole bridge erupts in laughter, which is probably trying just to break the tension of a fairly serious episode but does come across as terribly cheesy these days. And this probably sums up the episode as a whole – some interesting ideas and concepts, but ones that aren’t quite executed in a satisfying manner.

Planetary Gazetteer

Markus III: The planet to which the Enterprise is transporting medical supplies.

New Paris: Location of Earth colonies which are suffering a devastating plague and the ultimate destination of the medical supplies that the Enterprise is taking to Markus III.

Taurus II: The M-class planet on which the Galileo crashes. It is inhabited by a race of giant, primitive ape creatures (designated as Order 480G anthropoids).

Hansen’s Planet: Another planet that is home to Order 480G anthropoids, although these are smaller than those on Taurus II.

Starship Spotting

After the mention of the Enterprise having shuttlecraft in “The Conscience Of The King”, we now get an episode that revolves around one in the form of the Galileo. This is 24 feet in length and is labelled with the designation NCC1701/7. A second shuttlecraft, Columbus, is used to search for the Galileo.

General Observations

• A large number of Stardates are given, ranging between 2821.5 and 2823.8.
• The seven crew members of the title are Spock, McCoy, Scotty, Lt Latimer, Lt Gaetano, Lt Boma and Yeoman Mears. Latimer and Gaetano are both killed on Taurus II.
• We meet another Enterprise crew member, Lt Kelowitz, who was on a landing party searching Markus III. Other members of the landing party are mentioned – Ensign O’Neill (who is killed by the natives) and Lt Immamura (who suffered a dislocated shoulder and severe lacerations).
• McCoy seems to suggest that this episode shows Spock’s first command decisions, which seems somewhat unlikely given his position as First Officer on the Enterprise.
• Despite the shortcomings of the episode, it does feature some effective direction, especially a lovely – and atypical – shot of the bridge from above at the start of the episode.

Read more